It seems U.S. Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz, has caused a stir particularly with some Jewish groups following comments he made regarding religion and the 2008 presidential race.
McCain, a candidate for the Republican presidential nomination, was interviewed by Beliefnet.com and in the interview said the U.S. was established as a Christian nation and on Christian principles.
McCain is a Protestant who attends the North Phoenix Baptist Church and said that he would prefer that a person of his own faith be elected president. He also said a Muslim or other candidate could do a good job as president.
On Monday the McCain campaign clarified the senator's remarks claiming that he wasn't saying that persons of other religions have less of a claim to America.
"In the interview he also observed that the values protected by the Constitution, by which he meant values such as respect for human life and dignity, are rooted in the Judeo-Christian tradition," said Jill Hazelbaker, communications director for McCain's presidential effort. "That is all he intended to say to the question, America is a Christian nation, and it is hardly a controversial claim."
It just shows again how really messy things get when religion and politics get mixed up together. Any politician who shows any appearance of preferential support for one religious stance over another will of course run the risk of alienating all the others.
His campaign comms director is certainly right - the ethics and values of the USA are fundamentally founded in the Judaeo-christian tradition. Where McCain is wrong of course is to assume that the best or only upholders of these values are members of organised religious groups - or that they even need to be theists at all.
The one thing we certainly have maintained better over this side of the pond is trying to keep religion out of our parliamentary politics. We haven't always been good at this either of course. In fact arguably we have been slipping towards this more US approach with both Tony Blair and Gordon Brown actively making reference to their religious roots and beliefs and their political support for the growth of divisive faith schools.
Nevertheless at least we don't suffer from out and out faith based campaigns - yet?
Ayrshire Blog
"A Man's a Man for all that!" - Rabbie Burns
Oct 3, 2007
Related Posts by Categories
religion
- Falling down for Jesus
- Hitchens Secularism and Religious freedom
- The secrets of Scientology and My Story Winner
- Gateshead Six Arrested for burning Koran
- Jesus on Toast and Islamic Miracle Pictures
- The end of God? Horizon
- Evidence of the relationship between Nazis and Religion
- An atheist response to the Pope
- Hawking's God is a Dead Parrot
- Remembering the 9/11 Twin Towers attacks
- Christian and Muslim kooks out in force over Koran
- Dumb and Dumberer Creationists are scary
- Atheism or Critical Thinking
- The Atheist Ten Commandments
- Would you lie to save a Jew?
- How men create their Gods
- God made Phlegm? Why?
- God and other Top Shelf Stuff
- US beliefs about evolution
- The truth about Islam
- Islam and Free Speech
- Churchills Prophetic words on Islam
- UK police flee from Islamic Fundamentalists
- Does Morality come from religion or nature?
- India arrests editor for outraging muslims
politics
- Libya and the prospect of post-Islamist reform and renaissance
- #IamSpartacus say thousands on Twittter
- Angry Student demo in London
- Tommy Sheridan Perjury Trial of the decade?
- Ed Miliband Conference speech
- Ed Miliband wins labour party leadership election
- Michael Caine supports Labour in Election at Tory event
- Same old Conservatives
- Copenhagen Climate Changes Nothing
- Banking is a sorry business
- Gordon Brown -Another Tourettes outburst
- Gordon Brown - depression or disability?
- Sheridan Perjury Charges Go Ahead
- Obama has vision on energy security
- Geert Wilders - Religion is not Race
- President Obama - Hope and Possibility
- The Tories are right and I am going mad
- Israel Gaza Violence - Hamas fires its big guns
- Private enterprise hubris and the public good
- BNP Membership list leaked Scottish members
- Obama - the new American Future starts here
- The Evolution of American Politics?
- What future for Arctic nations?
- BBC Tories and Labour in murky affairs
- It's the economy-again-stupid
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Posts
3 comments:
As always, nothing is quite what it seems. The Democrats have been making egregious moves regarding religion for years, especially by showing up in the pulpit of black churches during campaign season. In the worst cases, a sermon is preached on voting Democrat, and then the congregation is packed onto buses and taken to an early voting location.
The Republican party has been a coalition of atheists, agnostics and conservative religious types. If that coalition can be split, then America is reduced to single party rule by Democrats. McCain is now in a damned if you do, damned if you don't position regarding Christianity because the main parts of the US media are still firmly under the control of the left. Whatever he does will be highlighted and presented to those who dislike it.
Sadly, I think the strategy of the left is going to work. We will become a big government country where the most unashamedly depraved people in society are the moral educators.
I think most people (especial in the politics or leadership) should understand the important of religion and how to implement it principles. Religion is very important according to me, however, it doe not mean that all people should be forced to follow a certain religion. A country is a big thing which simple means that there is different kinds of religion, hence politicians might be following a certain religion it does not necessarily mean that they must use their religion status to challenge voting’s. I think religion is very individual and democracy should be used instead to ensure that all people of different religions are respected...I will come back to discuss more after I have done an effective research based on this topic. Congratulation to the owner of this blog, keep it up...it is a nice work.
Kindly Regards
MR MALULEKE
Mr Malukele,
Thank you for your comments.
I agree with you that no one religion ( or any religion at all ) should be forced on people. People should be free to choose their own beliefs in a democracy and it is important that political leaders understand this and do not show favouratism to religion as a whole or to any particular religion.
You are welcome back to leave comments here anytime.
Post a Comment